Just a couple of years ago, I bonds were the hot savings account. Savings rates jumped to an impressive 9.62%, much higher than the near-zero rates we were seeing on many savings accounts. But as inflation cools, I bonds aren’t as popular as they once were.
The newest Series I savings bond rate was just released on May 1. From May 1, 2024, to Oct. 31, 2024, I bonds will earn a rate of 4.28%. That’s down from the previous rate of 5.27% they earned from Nov. 1, 2023, to April 30, 2024. But you can earn above 5% annual percentage yield, or APY, with today’s top CDs. Does that mean now’s the time to put your money in a CD instead of an I bond? It depends.
Since the new I bond rate has adjusted down, and CDs have been trending down as well, it’s tougher to determine which is a better deal for investors.
Ultimately, the best savings vehicle for you depends on your financial goals and how much you have available to invest.
What are I bonds?
I bonds are investment products backed by the federal government. They have both a fixed interest rate, which is set when you buy the bond, and a variable rate, which is tied to inflation and adjusted every six months. This variable rate is designed to protect your investments from inflation that could otherwise chip away at your money’s purchasing power.
I bonds are available from the US Treasury in increments of $25, with denominations from $25 to $1,000. You can buy up to $10,000 in I bonds each year, plus an additional $5,000 with your tax refund. You won’t pay state or local taxes on your I bond earnings, but you will pay federal taxes — although you may qualify for an exemption if you use the earnings to pay for higher education expenses.
You’ll need to leave money in an I bond for at least one year, but it’s better to leave your deposit in the treasury bond for a minimum of five years to avoid interest penalties.
How I bonds stack up against CDs
Both I bonds and CDs can offer a competitive return on your money. They both require an initial deposit which earns a set interest rate over a period of time. But your variable I bond rate will adjust every six months, while your CD rate is typically locked in.
I bonds also have some deposit limits and early withdrawal rules that CDs don’t have. Here’s a closer look at how the two savings vehicles compare:
| CDs | I bonds | |
| Where to buy | At a bank or credit union | Online via the US Treasury |
| Interest rate | Fixed, unless it’s a bump-up CD | A fixed and a derivative inflation rate |
| Term | Between 3 months and 5 years, depending on the bank | 1 to 30 years (but you shouldn’t withdraw before 5 years) |
| Minimum deposit requirement | Varies by bank | $25 |
| Can you make additional deposits? | No, unless it’s an add-on CD | Yes, but you can only purchase a maximum of $10,000 to $15,000 annually |
| Early withdrawal penalty | Yes, worth a certain amount of interest if you withdraw before maturity (no-penalty CDs don’t have early withdrawal fee) | You’ll forgo 3 months of interest if you withdraw before 5 years; minimum holding period of 12 years |
| Is your money protected? | CDs at FDIC-insured banks and NCUA-insured credit unions are insured for up to $250,000 per person, per account | I bonds are backed by the US government |
| How earnings are taxed | Subject to state and federal income tax | Exempt from local and state income tax; subject to federal tax (exemption for earnings spent on higher education) |
Should you put your money in an I bond or a CD?
I bonds and CDs are neck-and-neck right now, though you can lock in a slightly higher CD rate at some banks. So, the choice really comes down to when you’ll need your money, how much you have to invest and your risk tolerance.
When to choose a CD
If the investor is not trying to hedge inflation risk and the CD rate is higher (which it is now), I recommend investing in CDs.
- You’ll need your money soon. You can cash in an I bond after 12 months, but you’ll lose the previous three months’ interest if you access your funds before five years. CDs, on the other hand, come in terms as short as one month, making them well-suited for savers who’ll need their money faster.
- You want a fixed rate. If you like the predictability of guaranteed returns, you’ll…
Read More: I Bond Rates Are Down. Does That Mean You Should Choose a CD Instead?